Marcela Mitaynes

D · New York State Assembly, District 51 · Tier 5

Tier 5, “Critical on most positions”

Position

AD-51 incumbent (Sunset Park/Red Hook); NYC-DSA. Co-sponsor of the Not on Our Dime Act and a ceasefire and Palestinian-rights advocate.

Why this tier

Cosponsors ‘Not on Our Dime,’ was arrested twice in Oct 2023 at ceasefire protests (outside Schumer’s apartment and Gillibrand’s office) and again in August 2025 at a Gaza rally near Schumer’s home that called for an arms embargo, co-signed the Socialists-in-Office statement naming ‘the ongoing genocide in Gaza’ and ‘apartheid,’ and signed a JVP Action ceasefire letter. That combination — the material measure, genocide/apartheid framing, and sustained direct action — places her at Tier 5 for a state legislator and makes hers the strongest record among the Not-on-Our-Dime cosponsors rostered at Tier 5. She settles at 5 rather than 5/6 because she holds no position questioning Israel’s legitimacy — no BDS by name, anti-Zionist self-identification, rejection of Israel as a Jewish state or support for the right of return. Cosponsoring the bill is a measure, not a position on Israel’s legitimacy.

Open the full card, with votes, money and every source, on elect26 →

elect26 places 2026 midterm candidates on a six-tier spectrum, from 1 (most pro-Israel) to 6 (most critical of Israel).