How the Ratings Work

Every candidate is placed on a six-point scale — from firmly pro-Israel (1) to most critical of Israel and supportive of Palestine (6) — using three kinds of evidence: how they vote, what they say, and who funds and endorses them.

A short guide to the method · as of October 22, 2026

The six-point scale

The scale measures how far a candidate is willing to pull back support for Israel — not a plan for Palestinians, which almost no one in U.S. elections runs on.

1
Firmly pro-IsraelUnqualified, active support. Reaching this level takes leadership, not just reliability.
2
Mainstream pro-IsraelDependable support without leading on it.
3
Pro-Israel, criticalStill backs Israel, but criticizes how it is fighting, or takes a single step toward limiting weapons.
4
Critical / conditions aidA real record of trying to withhold offensive weapons, short of a full arms embargo.
5
Critical on most positionsBacks a full weapons embargo, defensive systems included, or cutting off all aid — firmly and consistently.
6
Most critical of Israel / supports PalestineChallenges whether Israel should exist as a Jewish state — identifying as anti-Zionist, backing BDS by name, or supporting the Palestinian right of return — with a real record and no hedging.

What we look at

What weighs most

Ratings are judgments

None of this is a formula. A candidate’s full record can override any general rule, and many ratings turn on details no general rule anticipates. Every rating is written out on the candidate’s entry, under Why this tier, so it can be checked, argued with, and revised as the record changes.

Who’s included

Spotted something wrong? Send a correction with a link to the source. This page is a companion to the roster.

Made by the elect26 project · © 2026